Knowledge

Different control system types

01 Aug 2017 - Projects

We often get asked the difference between DCS and PLC/SCADA-based systems, and where PACs come in to it. So here's an attempt to clear things up.

History

DCSs (Distributed Control Systems) were originally developed to control large industrial processes and typically have a number of autonomous controllers located across a plant. With microprocessors running control algorithms in the field, central computers were left to provide the operator interface, and this proved more reliable than centralised control architectures.
The control function block concept was also a key feature of early DCSs, a single entity which provided both the logic and graphical interface to control equipment. Because the two were created together, subsequent modification and expansion of the system was relatively easy.

PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers), on the other hand, first addressed the needs of the car manufacturers. Modular devices, that were more flexible than discrete controllers, relays and sensors, PLCs could be reprogrammed allowing assembly lines to be modified and updated without re-wiring individual devices. PLCs were also resilient to hot and dusty shop floor environments, not suitable for the digital computers of the time.

While we're at it... RTUs (Remote Terminal Units) are sometimes called Remote Telemetry Units due to their suitability for connecting geographically diverse pieces of equipment to a SCADA. RTUs traditionally communicated wirelessly and couldn't execute control algorithms, but are otherwise functionally similar to PLCs.

SCADA (Supervisory Control And Data Acquisition) systems were typically networked computers providing graphical interfaces, data collection and storage facilities to a wide variety of PLCs and RTUs. SCADA solutions were first adopted where equipment was located across vast distances, for example the water, gas and electrical networks.

Today

With the adoption of more 'open' communication standards, little separates modern DCS and PLC/SCADA solutions. DCSs used to be based on proprietary technology but now bear more resemblance to PLC/SCADA systems to benefit from widely available technology. Likewise, manufacturers of traditional SCADAs now make importing PLC taglists into system databases almost automatic, making configuration changes more DCS-like.

PLC and RTU technology has also converged, with either able to communicate wirelessly or run control algorithms.

To describe higher-spec units many vendors now use the term PAC (Programmable Automation Controller). PACs tend to have more memory, connectivity options and faster CPUs than a 'standard' PLC.

So which do you need?

This will be covered in detail with another post, coming soon.


 

3 ways to get started right now


New? Dip a toe in

Let Richard serve you regular breakfast emails. Useful information for those lookng to make improvements to their operations, from project justification to reminders about the importance of security and disaster recovery.

Knowledge and insights into your inbox.



  Receive Richard's emails  

Arrange a site audit

Have one of our experienced engineers visit your site to review your existing operations, discuss how we can help and provide you with a prioritised action plan describing how to improve your operations.

A free, no obligation service.



 Book an appointment online 

Immediate problem?

Need assistance right away? We have expertise with a wide variety of automation equipment and software. So if you're looking for help get in touch and we'll do everything we can.

We offer support agreements so there's always someone on the end of the line.



    Give us a call right away    



More from Projects


← Prev   Next →